The Pagan Christ



What if it could be proved that Jesus never existed? What if there was evidence that every word of the New Testament is based on myth and metaphor? And what if those revelations extended beyond Christianity, putting into question even the fundamental beliefs of Judaism and Islam?

These are the ideas presented in The Pagan Christ, a documentary based on theologian Tom Harpur's explosive, best-selling book. Using an investigative reporting approach to the topic, the cameras journey from the Egyptian temple at Luxor and the Great Pyramids of Giza to Vatican City and Jerusalem's wailing wall.

What do you think about the ideas presented in this film?
Previous
Next

Comments

eel_shepherd said…
One thing you can always count on from guys like Harpur, in the early days of their reconsideration of their longterm religion, but before they've decided that they've had enough of it (if they ever do), is the departure from normal English speech. He talks about the recognition of "what you really are" right at the very end of the documentary. This is not the cornflakes. You can go to Safeway, and in the Safeway is a pallet; and on the pallet are a bunch of cartons; and in the cartons is a bunch of boxes; and in each box is a bag; and in the bag is the cornflakes. All you ever get from the Harpurs at the stage we see him at in the documentary is a guy who is ready to talk about the boxes, where he once talked about the cartons. Or he's ready to talk about the bags, where he once talked about the boxes. Forget it. Everyone is entitled to the cornflakes, not the layers of packaging. And Harpur's still talking about the package. For some of us, that doesn't cut it. There's no need to depart from normal speech if you actually know what you're talking about, and if Harpur does know, then he's doing a pretty poor job of conveying it for a person who passes himself off as a communicator. Who he thinks he's snowing, I don't know.
May 15, 2008
speck said…
I had a few alarms going off in my brain as I watched this...

....."Your getting sleeeepy, sleeeeeeepy"........

By the time it ended I felt like I'd be suckered into an Amway ambush.

Time will tell......
May 16, 2008
Unknown said…
Thanks for the video. But, still, Harpur seems to be saying, "I found evidence that the whole tooth fairy thing is a lie. People long ago fabricated a story and exterminated those who didn't go along with the official version. This made me come to the realization that instead of believing in the tooth fairy, we just need to find the fairy in each of us." I'd agree up until the last sentence. If something is completely made up, there's no reason why you should assume something else without evidence. So if there's no Jesus, then is there still salvation? If there is salvation, then does the Old Testament talk about it? Would believing that simply make you a Jew? Anyway, the Egyptians made up Horus (based just on the sun, which they didn't understand), so Christianity's whole premise is based on a misunderstanding. There's no reason to even try to salvage it, unless you're just trying to save face after believing such a blatant lie (which even I once did) for so long.
May 16, 2008
Aaron said…
I get the impression that everyone who commented on this is feeling that his holding on to "Christian values" despite the lack of true history is misleading.

However, he seems to be admitting that it is all an allegory about the subjective experience of self-actualization. He's not even saying it's the only allegory, it's just the one he identifies with most.

His faith is focused on the subjective experience rather than the claim of objective facts, and there's nothing wrong with that. If I find a piece of music, a work of fiction, or a movie inspiring, I'll *know* that it is not reality, but focusing on that fact the whole time ruins the experience and strips it of its value to me. I get the impression that this man is trying to convey his religion has taken on a similar status.

I give kudos for his honesty, his thorough search, and still finding fulfillment in all of it.
May 21, 2008

Post a Comment

Recently popular posts:

Dear Believer

433 comments
by Dan Barker Dear Believer, — You asked me to consider Christianity as the answer for my life. I have done that. I consider it untrue, repugnant, and harmful. You expect me to believe Jesus was born of a virgin impregnated by a ghost? Do you believe all the crazy tales of ancient religions? Julius Caesar was reportedly born of a virgin; Roman historian Seutonius said Augustus bodily rose to heaven when he died; and Buddha was supposedly born speaking. You don’t believe all that, do you? Why do you expect me to swallow the fables of Christianity? I find it incredible that you ask me to believe that the earth was created in six literal days; women come from a man’s rib; a snake, a donkey, and a burning bush spoke human language; the entire world was flooded, covering the mountains to drown evil; all animal species, millions of them, rode on one boat; language variations stem from the tower of Babel; Moses had a magic wand; the Nile turned to blood; a stick turned into a snake; witches, ...
Read more

Logical Proof that God doesn't exist - Prayer

241 comments
By Sailorfraud The Bible says God is almighty who answers your prayers. So how do you know if God is real other than that faith crap? Try the power of prayer when an earthly situation occurs which is beyond your control and only an almighty God who created the universe and all life can control. Suppose you or a close family member has a terminal disease like cancer which cannot be medically cured? A certain time line is given, so like all hopeful human beings, you humbly and diligently pray to the almighty God who says in the Bible he answers prayers. Time and reality passes, the disease takes it's toll, and your prayers go unanswered. Maybe one in a million may be saved, but looking at a 99.9999% failure rate for prayer is evidence that God does not exist. Now, compare it to an atheist who suffers the same terminal disease and wishes for healing. The same 99.9999% failure rate occurs. Now compare it to a devout Muslim suffering the same terminal disease and prays to his/her ...
Read more

Jesus...f*** you

189 comments
By Ian Hi Jesus. Jet me start out by saying F*** you. Yeah, that's right. F*** you. F*** you uncle f***er. What the f***? you ask. Allow me to explain. After careful consideration and a lot of thinking, I have come to the conclusion that you, as presented in the Bible and your followers, are a f***er. How so? Let's see. If people don't believe in you, you damn them to hell. Real nice and merciful. If you damn people to hell for not believing in you and thus harming your ego, then f*** you. If you damn people to hell for following Christianity, then f*** you. If you're going to damn ME for being a freethinker and a humanist, then you're a really psychotic son of God. Want to change your image Jesus? How about starting off by getting rid of all your spokespersons. Why not start with Billy Graham? He's a big motherf***er. I mean come on, wrinkly as a prune, thinks Satan is out to ruin the world, threatens us with hell if we don't believe, runs ...
Read more

"A Sabbatical?" or "My Anti-Testimony"

476 comments
I first posted this "testimony" to the web on July 27, 2001. If you too have found Christianity specifically, or religion generally, to be less than satisfying for any reason, please consider posting your own "testimony" to this site by clicking here , or message me by clicking here. I t is invariably a shock to Evangelical Christians to come across someone who has turned his or her back on the “faith was once delivered unto the saints.” Most believers will quickly dismiss an ex-Christian by piously pointing out that anyone who turns away from Christ was never a real believer. Or, as an insider might say it, “They were never born again.” There is Biblical support for the assertion. 1 John 2:19, which addressed the problem of First Century apostates, states that: “They went out from us, but they were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would no doubt have continued with us: but they went out, that they might be made manifest that they were not all of us....
Read more

  Books purchased here help support ExChristian.Net!