How about leaving some names for this game, and/or some rules in the comments section! Isn't this fun? If we do well, maybe we could market it!
"Most people are religious, so assume it is true."
"God is the cause of existence; things exist; therefore God exists."
"You just don't understand it, too blind to see
"Everything must have a cause - except my God"
( science can't explain it, therefore God must have done it )
Argumentum ad Theoblatero
"All Xians are good; bad people are not Xian; so Xians are all good."
"I know because I know"